Disc 1

1. Silent Night
2. All I Want for Christmas Is You
3. O Holy Night
4. Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)
5. Miss You Most (U Christmas Time)
6. Joy to the World
7. Jesus, Born on This Day
8. Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town
9. Hark the Herald Angels Sing/Gloria (In Excelsis Deo)
10. Jesus Oh What a Wonderful Child
11. God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen

Disc 2

12. Sugar Plum Fairy (Interlude)
13. All I Want for Christmas Is You [Live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine]
14. Silent Night [Live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine]
15. Joy to the World [Live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine]
16. Hark the Herald Angels Sing/Gloria (In Excelsis Deo) [Live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine]
17. Jesus Born on This Day [Live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine]
18. Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town [Live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine]
19. Oh Santa!
20. Christmas Time Is in the Air Again
21. When Christmas Comes (Duet With John Legend)
22. The Star
23. Lil Snowman
24. Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town [Anniversary Mix]
25. All I Want for Christmas Is You [So So Def Remix]
26. All I Want for Christmas Is You [Mariahs New Dance Mix Edit Extended 2009]
27. Joy to the World [Celebration Mix]
28. Joy to the World [Flavia Mix]
29. Sugar Plum Fairy (Interlude) (Acapella)